Three Editors Agree, These Under-$40 Shoes From Amazon Are So Worth It

Products you buy through our links may earn us a commission. Oh, and if something's out of stock, oops, it was there (and all prices were accurate) at time of publication.

What We Tested…

• Dream Pairs Block Heel Mule Sandals ($36.99)

• Dream Pairs Foldable Ballet Flats ($34.99)

Why Abby Tested...

Test Results...

• Dream Pairs Block Heel Mule Sandals (silver): I wore these shoes twice for five to six hours each around the city and had zero pain in the ball of my foot or my heels. The platform and heel combo helped me feel stable while walking. As for the design, I love the ‘90s vibe. I got the metallic silver color and felt so trendy whenever I threw them on. I appreciated that they have more of a brushed look (meaning they’re not overly shiny), which made it easier to pair with more outfits, like jeans and a tank for a daytime look. I didn’t see any peeling or scuffing, either. 

Why Alessandra Tested...

Test Results...

• Dream Pairs Block Heel Mule Sandals (silver): These shoes look exactly like they do in the pictures. They’re sleek, but statement-making. I wore mine out around the city and on a boat for an anniversary date. I felt supported and comfortable for the entire seven-hour excursion. I also wore these with jean shorts and a tank for an easy day-to-night look and got a lot of compliments. They don’t require any time to break in. They’re not sweaty feet-friendly, but other than that, I was very impressed.

Why Margo Tested...

Test Results...

• Dream Pairs Foldable Ballet Flats (nude): From the moment I tried on this shoe, I could feel the insole’s comfy memory foam cushioning. It felt like I wasn’t wearing shoes at all. The substantially textured outer sole has grip that makes walking comfortable and not slippery. As for the look, everything about this shoe feels chic and put together thanks to its bow detailing and overall shape. I went for the nude color and am happy to report that I can wear them with pretty much everything in my closet. That being said, I appreciate that they come in so many colors. With an under-$40 price tag, I am definitely planning to buy a brighter pair. I loved the elastic backing at the heel for added comfort and had zero rubbing, break-in periods, or blisters. I can also confirm these flats are very foldable and (bonus) come with their own drawstring storage bag. I found them to be easy to pack and throw in my work bag, which is huge if you’re a commuter. 

Sidenotes...

• Both of these styles are available on Prime for two-day shipping or less. 

• Both styles come in sizes 6-11. 

• Dream Pairs Block Heel Mule Sandals: These shoes are not available in wide sizes, only regular. Both testers expressed the need for wide sizing, as the toe strap can feel snug even after breaking them in. 

• Dream Pairs Foldable Ballet Flats: These shoes are made of a faux-leather/polyvinyl material. Because of that, the texture looks a little plasticky, according to Margo. 

The Fine Details…

• Dream Pairs Block Heel Mule Sandals ($36.99)

• Dream Pairs Foldable Ballet Flats ($34.99)

  • Available in regular and wide sizes