I’ve Tried Dozens of Drugstore Lipsticks, and These Are the 7 Best Under $15

Finish: Satin | Format: Bullet | Shades: 52

I fell in love with L’Oréal’s Colour Riche Original Satin Lipstick at first swipe. It’s creamy, packed with pigment, and keeps my lips smooth and velvety. It’s also long-lasting, and I experienced minimal transferring during eating and drinking, and throughout wear, it didn’t bleed or feather outside my lip lines. If you have to reapply it after a large meal, it layers beautifully without becoming cakey—a testament to its lightweight and moisturizing formula. It also comes in over 50 shades, including Berry Parisienne, the beautiful mauve hue pictured above. One tradeoff is that the lipstick has a potent fragrance, which might be unpleasant for people with sensitive skin or nose.

Finish: Satin | Format: Bullet | Shades: 20

If you want a long-wearing satin lipstick with incredible color payoff, consider e.l.f. Cosmetics’ O Face Satin Lipstick. With just one coat, I achieved smooth, even pigmentation—and once applied, the lipstick didn’t bleed outside my lip lines or bunch up at the sides of my mouth. What was more impressive was how long it lasted. The lipstick stayed intact after I ate and drank, offering the longevity one might usually expect of a matte lipstick. If anything, it isn’t as lightweight as the other satin lipsticks I swiped on, but it’s a small price to pay for its long-lasting wear. I wore the shade Drive, a medium-brown hue, but you can choose from 19 other colors, ranging from classic neutrals to reds, pinks, and violets, and one dark, deep black aptly named All Night.

Finish: Matte | Format: Bullet | Shades: 14

The Maybelline Color Sensational Ultimatte Slim Lipstick is lightweight and stays comfortable on the lips throughout wear—and it comes recommended by Badro. Just one swipe offers an even layer of color, and I loved that the lipstick applied smoothly without emphasizing the texture of my lips. As for its longevity, you might have to reapply it after eating; I ate a chicken sandwich while wearing it, and the color faded slightly after my meal. However, reapplication is made easy with the slim bullet, which allows for precise application. I sampled the color More Rust, a brick-red shade, but initially choosing among the 13 other options proved challenging—it comes in a wide range of deliciously wearable shades ranging from sandy nude to purple mauve to cocoa brown.

Finish: High-Shine | Format: Liquid | Shades: 20

Maybelline’s Vinyl Ink Liquid Lipcolor comes with the recommendation of Alves. Alves says, “It is long-wearing, andthe colors havea lot of oomph tothem.” I can attest that the liquid lipstick offers intense color in just one swipe while imparting a lacquered sheen that applies and wears smoothly on the lips. I opted to try the Ret Hot shade (a fire-engine red) and the doe-foot applicator made for easy and precise application. It takes a few minutes to set, but once it does, it stays put, and better yet, it doesn’t settle into lines, crease, or fade. If anything, it can feel slightly tacky on the lips but not so much as to be unpleasant to wear. On the contrary, it feels weightless, which is rare for a long-lasting liquid product. What’s more, it’s available in 20 shades, and if you aren’t keen on its high-shine finish, opt for the Maybelline SuperStay Matte Ink ($11), which Alves also highly recommends.

Finish: High-shine | Format: Liquid | Shades: 35

The NYX Butter Gloss is a cult favorite for good reason. It has a highly pigmented gel-like formula that is neither too sticky or slippery, and just one or two coats deliver full and even coverage. The gloss has the lightweight feel of a balm, with an understated shine that lent my lips a juicy-looking appearance. Its doe-foot applicator makes it easy to deliver the gloss where you want it and without missing any spots—and once applied, you won’t have to worry about it transferring or migrating around your mouth. If anything, I had to reapply it after eating and drinking, but other than that, it stayed right where I wanted it—on my lips—without fading. You can select from among 35 colors, from everyday neutrals to bold and bright pops of color. I opted for Red Velvet, a deep red hue that is equal parts playful and sophisticated.

Finish: Satin | Format: Bullet | Shades: 84

Makeup artists and celebrities love the Revlon Super Lustrous Lipstick, and it’s easy to see why. Its satin formula is creamy, buildable, and hydrating, and it doesn’t bleed or settle into lip lines. While the formula is excellent, its expansive shade range makes it a cut above the competition. It currently comes in over 80 shades (including the Black Cherry shade pictured above) that range in cool, warm, and neutral undertones, so everyone should be able to find a color (or three) that suits their preferences. Keep in mind that since this is a satin lipstick, it will wear off when eating or drinking. However, it’s a cinch to reapply—the lipstick glides onto the lips easily and offers a one-swipe color payoff.

Finish: Satin | Format: Stick | Shades: 17

The Neutrogena MoistureSmooth Color Stick is akin to wearing a balm but delivers the high-impact pigment most would want from a lipstick. It’s comfortable and lightweight on the lips, and just one swipe deposits rich pigmentation. It’s easy to apply, too: The lipstick looks like a crayon, making coloring within my lips’ outer lines a breeze. The color remained intact throughout the day. However, I had to apply it after eating—a process that required little to no effort, thanks to its convenient applicator. Overall, I loved the barely-there feel of the lipstick and how moisturizing it is—in fact, it left my lips soft and smooth long after wear, earning it bonus points in my book. I selected the Pink Nude shade, but there are 16 more options, including pinks, reds, and browns.