Acquisition gets the attention, but loyalty drives the results

Marketing teams face more pressure than ever to fill the pipeline and acquire new customers. With access to more data and analytics than ever before, it’s no surprise that business leaders and stakeholders are focused on acquisition, too.

The problem arises when that focus overshadows one of your most valuable assets — your existing customers. Retaining customers, and even cross-selling or upselling them, costs less and delivers stronger results than attracting new ones. 

You’ve already earned their business and, ideally, kept them happy through great service and support. Those customers are far more likely to buy again, leave positive reviews and refer others.

It sounds easy — so why doesn’t everyone do it?

The problem with customer loyalty and nurturing programs is that, while they’re highly effective, they’re also hard. They require:

• A strong strategic approach.
• Thoughtful segmentation of your customer lists (because blasting the same message to everyone won’t resonate).
• A consistent cadence for your messaging and nurture campaigns. 

These more complex strategies may demand additional resources — either technology or dedicated team hours — but the payoff can be huge. You’ll see conversion rates climb along with brand equity from referrals and positive reviews. 

Aside from the extra time investment, the budget impact is minimal. These aren’t paid media campaigns or other efforts that require large ad spends.

Dig deeper: 6 ways email marketing can elevate customer engagement and loyalty

What if I don’t have a large team — can this be automated?

The good news is that many tools for nurture and customer loyalty campaigns come with automation and scheduling features built in. Think HubSpot, Mailchimp, ActiveCampaign and others. Here are a few ways to put automation to work.

Customer welcome and onboarding emails

These matter because a customer’s first post-purchase experience can make or break their impression of your company — and whether they become loyal. If someone buys your product and struggles to use it, they’ll want quick support. 

But if they receive a proactive welcome email with FAQs before reaching out to customer service, they’re instantly happier. This simple touch shows that you thought about them after the sale (even if it’s automated) — a significant win.

Follow-up check-ins

An automated email — or even a quick call — around the one-month mark to check in on progress can make customers feel valued. That small gesture turns good service into rockstar service and helps transform satisfied buyers into brand evangelists.

Post-purchase upsell and loyalty offers

After a few weeks, when customers are enjoying your product, you can reach out with suggestions for complementary products or offer a discount to loyal customers. They already trust your brand, and they’re far more likely to buy again.

Dig deeper: An email automation blueprint for smarter customer journeys

Extending loyalty beyond email

Absolutely. Loyalty and nurturing strategies can extend well beyond email. If you have a modest advertising budget, retargeting campaigns using customer lists can be a veritable gold mine. 

Retargeting existing customers who’ve already made a purchase is a powerful way to introduce new products, upsell to premium offerings or invite them to join VIP or loyalty programs with exclusive discounts. These re-engagement efforts often deliver higher conversion rates and are more cost-effective than targeting cold audiences — because these customers already love your brand.

Another straightforward, low-cost option is a rewards program that offers exclusive discounts or coupons for referrals or online reviews. Please note that some review platforms, such as Yelp, prohibit incentivizing reviews.

Dig deeper: Who’s advocating for your email subscribers?

You can also use email or retargeting to re-engage dormant customers — those who have purchased once and then become inactive. They saw enough value to buy before, but may have felt overlooked. 

A simple reminder can go a long way. Try an email campaign for customers who haven’t engaged in a year or more — no opens, no repurchases — and offer a discount to draw them back. Often, they just need a slight nudge.

Finally, customers appreciate brands that provide support and educate. Create email or video campaigns that answer FAQs, explain product features or show how to get the most value from their purchase. These proactive touches build trust, strengthen loyalty and position your company as the go-to authority in your space.

The long game of customer loyalty

While most marketing teams focus on lead generation and new customer acquisition, retention and loyalty programs deliver longer-term results. Conversions become easier and less expensive, brand reputation grows stronger and overall ROI improves. 

New customer acquisition will always matter — especially in early growth phases — but retaining, nurturing and turning existing customers into advocates pays far greater dividends.

Dig deeper: Measuring new customer acquisition and loyalty: Best of the MarTechBot

The post Acquisition gets the attention, but loyalty drives the results appeared first on MarTech.